Re: Oklahoma City, In the Press
Originally Posted by
PhiAlpha
I'm not really sure why you seem to have a constant axe to grind against Tulsa but there's nothing wrong with people from there taking issue with posters here saying things like:
You and everyone here (I'm assuming), but you especially, know that it's disingenuous to use the city population numbers to compare growth between the two cities and act like OKC legitimately grew 51 times more than Tulsa did last year. OKC makes up nearly 10% of the total MSA area and Tulsa makes up just over 3% of the Tulsa MSA. I've lived in both cities for multiple years at a time recently so maybe I'm one of few here is actually capable of being objective.
If you aren't using the MSA statistics, you don't care about reality and what actually matters when discussing the growth of a city. It's true that OKC is the larger city and is growing faster, but it's also true that the city population numbers don't tell anywhere close to the whole story. Percentage change wise, they aren't that far off (especially the 2022-2023 estimates). The MSA statistics:
OKC MSA
2020: 1,425,695
2023: 1,477,926
Diff: 52,231
%: 3.66%
2022: 1,459,957
Diff: 17,969
%: 1.23%
Tulsa MSA
2020: 1,015,331
2023: 1,044,757
Diff: 29,426
%: 2.90%
2022: 1,034,048
Diff: 10,709
%: 1.04%
but OKC isn't growing in it's rural areas in raw numbers like Tulsan's always try to say. OKC's growth is in the core and established areas NW, W, and SW. OKC has more opportunity in those areas but its not expanding in rural NE, SE. OKC does make up half of the OKC metro pop, but one should not discount the municipal pop as it is what the census uses to measure cities and make appropriations. OKC is significantly bigger than Tulsa in that regard *almost double, even if Tulsa took the same area.
We could argue the same about metro area, Tulsa's metro land area is larger than OKC's, hence why Tulsa is now able to get to 1 million, while census takes away Shawnee from OKC metro even though it is literally a few miles away from OKC limits and is connected to the city. ...
Rover is correct, Tulsan's should accept that OKC is bigger, always has been. That's ok you know, it benefits Tulsa to have a successful OKC competing against other state's largest cities. ...
Oklahoma City, the RENAISSANCE CITY!
Bookmarks