Widgets Magazine
Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 53

Thread: Violence and Mental Health

  1. #1

    Default Violence and Mental Health

    The outcry regarding another horrific mass shooting is justified. While the conversations pointing blame on the result of violence the conversations regarding the cause seem to be lacking. It seems when combining an overwhelming love/interest in our country violence from entertainment ie; movies, music, gaming along with an alarming rise in mental health issues -these two issues create the perfect storm for violent outburst as we tragically see in Texas. Even in Tulsa this week, one homeless man stabbed another homeless man to death and reports state 'mental illness'.

    While talk of gun control, etc are justified in part -the larger and more difficult issue is how to deal with so much mental illness. Its my hope that among those in leadership we can hear of possible help for so many in our country who mental illness is a danger to others and themselves.

    No easy answers -but its vital we devote time and resources toward helping the mentally ill.

  2. #2

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    The USA is not an outlier among the countries of the world with more mental illness than others.
    Unfortunatly this gets mentioned as a way to avoid what the variable is in this country compared to other societies.
    If the cause was truly mental illness then where is the funding to treat it?

  3. #3

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by bucktalk View Post
    The outcry regarding another horrific mass shooting is justified. While the conversations pointing blame on the result of violence the conversations regarding the cause seem to be lacking. It seems when combining an overwhelming love/interest in our country violence from entertainment ie; movies, music, gaming along with an alarming rise in mental health issues -these two issues create the perfect storm for violent outburst as we tragically see in Texas. Even in Tulsa this week, one homeless man stabbed another homeless man to death and reports state 'mental illness'.

    While talk of gun control, etc are justified in part -the larger and more difficult issue is how to deal with so much mental illness. Its my hope that among those in leadership we can hear of possible help for so many in our country who mental illness is a danger to others and themselves.

    No easy answers -but its vital we devote time and resources toward helping the mentally ill.
    Basic comparative politics shows that this argument doesn't really get at the root cause. The US isn't an outlier among modern developed democracies when it comes to diagnoses of mental illnesses, counselors per capita or total spent on mental health. Neither is the US an outlier when it comes to access to violent movies, video games or music as our media is consumed all aorund the world.

    What makes us different, and why these tragedies happen more here than any other developed democracy on earth, is guns.

    Addressing mental health is good. Better healthcare overall is good. But we're fooling ourselves if we think that these measures will somehow stop events like yesterday from happening if we don't concurrently address guns.

  4. #4

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by Jersey Boss View Post
    The USA is not an outlier among the countries of the world with more mental illness than others.
    Unfortunatly this gets mentioned as a way to avoid what the variable is in this country compared to other societies.
    If the cause was truly mental illness then where is the funding to treat it?
    But most other developed nations have some form of nationalized healthcare and the US doesn't even though US citizens spend more on healthcare with less actual healthcare unless you are a veteran like myself and have socialized healthcare which every citizen should have the right to healthcare

    Most people can't afford mental healthcare in the US.

    Countries with universal healthcare include Austria, Belarus, Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Iceland, Isle of Man, Italy, Luxembourg, Malta, Moldova, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Russia, Serbia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Ukraine, and the United Kingdom.

    Sure, in the US if you have access to a ton of money you get great everything and anything you need/want which is about 1% of the population

    https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/...e-countries-2/

  5. #5

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Nationalized healthcare and treating MI are two different things that should not be part of the same discussion when regarding mass murder and the causes.
    The link below addresses this and the lack of mental illness treatment in countries not expieriencing the carnage that we face on a weekly basis.


    https://m.dw.com/en/pay-up-or-put-it...lth/a-56812344

  6. #6

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by Jersey Boss View Post
    Nationalized healthcare and treating MI are two different things that should not be part of the same discussion when regarding mass murder and the causes.
    The link below addresses this and the lack of mental illness treatment in countries not expieriencing the carnage that we face on a weekly basis.


    https://m.dw.com/en/pay-up-or-put-it...lth/a-56812344
    I disagree about healthcare and mental healthcare being two different things they are both healthcare. That is like saying dental and vision are not the same as healthcare it makes zero sense.

    Maybe the world needs to take a look at how the VA in the US handles healthcare. I have zero issues getting mental healthcare using the VA in OKC or any other place I have lived. Access to healthcare is better than no access at all same with mental healthcare.

    Of course easy access to firearms and having it in the constitution makes it very difficult.

    This a good site

    https://www.william-russell.com/blog...al-healthcare/

  7. #7

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    You might disagree but then why are people in these countries with guaranreed healthcare not getting treated? And why are these untreated people not shooting up schools?
    As far as dental not being covered healthcare , have you been to the UK?
    Read the link I provided.

  8. #8

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by Jersey Boss View Post
    You might disagree but then why are people in these countries with guaranreed healthcare not getting treated? And why are these untreated people not shooting up schools?
    As far as dental not being covered healthcare , have you been to the UK?
    Read the link I provided.
    they are getting treated just not 56% of them, like I said some care is better than none and the US's problem of the 2nd amendment and the ease of access to firearms along with no affordable access to mental health care

    I have been to the UK, Germany, Turkey, South Korea, Japan and Canada plus a few other countries and I read the link you provided

  9. #9

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by Jersey Boss View Post
    You might disagree but then why are people in these countries with guaranreed healthcare not getting treated? And why are these untreated people not shooting up schools?
    As far as dental not being covered healthcare , have you been to the UK?
    Read the link I provided.
    This a good site as well

    crazy, seems across the board that countries do not invest much into mental health care

    https://www.commonwealthfund.org/pub...ther-countries

  10. #10

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    It's not just the ease of access to guns, it's an entire American gun culture that goes back for generations.

    I've mentioned this before but guns are way, way more common in places like Oklahoma where many people grew up shooting in rural areas and/or hunting.

    Compare to somewhere like L.A. where even though there is much more violent crime, guns are not part of the culture at all. Same is true in most big cities.

    Yet, I have friends in gated communities in Edmond that swear they need guns "to protect their family". Almost all of these people grew in areas or families where guns had been a part of their life. Also, somewhere along the line the NRA went from a gun safety and recreation group to being on the constant warpath in the culture wars.

    It's something that is handed down from generation to generation, it's just that a lot of these people now live in suburbs rather than on farms or in small towns.

  11. #11

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by Pete View Post
    It's not just the ease of access to guns, it's an entire American gun culture that goes back for generations.

    I've mentioned this before but guns are way, way more common in places like Oklahoma where many people grew up shooting in rural areas and/or hunting.

    Compare to somewhere like L.A. where even though there is much more violent crime, guns are not part of the culture at all. Same is true in most big cities.

    Yet, I have friends in gated communities in Edmond that swear they need guns "to protect their family". Almost all of these people grew in areas or families where guns had been a part of their life. Also, somewhere along the line the NRA went from a gun safety and recreation group to being on the constant warpath in the culture wars.

    It's something that is handed down from generation to generation, it's just that a lot of these people now live in suburbs rather than on farms or in small towns.
    I don't disagree with what you said but I do believe ease of access is crazy in the U.S.

    when I bought my HK 9mm I did it on my lunch hour, walked out with a firearm and ammo in 20 minutes.

  12. #12

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    The ease of access is directly related to the culture.

    It's seriously embedded in the U.S. and thus nearly impossible to change, especially with the past influence of the NRA. But their power has been greatly diminished, so maybe that will be the first step towards some sort of sanity.

  13. #13

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by shartel_ave View Post
    I don't disagree with what you said but I do believe ease of access is crazy in the U.S.

    when I bought my HK 9mm I did it on my lunch hour, walked out with a firearm and ammo in 20 minutes.
    Word.

  14. #14

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    As a conservative and supporter of the 2A, I'm at the point where I would accept expanded background checks as a fact of life. In order to get a CCP in Canadian County I had to jump through a lot of hoops before it was issued, i.e. fingerprint, background check, training, and the approval of the County Sheriff. I thought this was a PITA but reasonable when considering the responsibility and privilege I was being given. I imagine that in most Counties the mentally ill are probably known by LE due to the probability that they have come up on the "radar" at some point. Constitutional Carry did away with the requirements for an extensive background check...I think. Also, it's a shame that we have to do it, but I'm supportive of expanded security measures at EVERY school in Oklahoma. The money we've thrown away on foreign matters could be more wisely used to beef up security in our schools. I'm not going to go into detail but I have been a Security Consultant and performed inspections and made recommendations for enhanced security for many large Companies. Access control should be at the forefront of a good plan for our schools. It wouldn't be too expensive to lockdown schools and provide all authorized students and personnel with keycards, etc. Video cameras are relatively inexpensive and when used with "mantrap" entrances they would provide pretty fair security. Like I said, it's a shame we're at this point, but it is what it is. I don't believe taking guns away from honest citizens would help much.

  15. #15

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by Oklapatriot View Post
    As a conservative and supporter of the 2A, I'm at the point where I would accept expanded background checks as a fact of life. In order to get a CCP in Canadian County I had to jump through a lot of hoops before it was issued, i.e. fingerprint, background check, training, and the approval of the County Sheriff. I thought this was a PITA but reasonable when considering the responsibility and privilege I was being given. I imagine that in most Counties the mentally ill are probably known by LE due to the probability that they have come up on the "radar" at some point. Constitutional Carry did away with the requirements for an extensive background check...I think. Also, it's a shame that we have to do it, but I'm supportive of expanded security measures at EVERY school in Oklahoma. The money we've thrown away on foreign matters could be more wisely used to beef up security in our schools. I'm not going to go into detail but I have been a Security Consultant and performed inspections and made recommendations for enhanced security for many large Companies. Access control should be at the forefront of a good plan for our schools. It wouldn't be too expensive to lockdown schools and provide all authorized students and personnel with keycards, etc. Video cameras are relatively inexpensive and when used with "mantrap" entrances they would provide pretty fair security. Like I said, it's a shame we're at this point, but it is what it is. I don't believe taking guns away from honest citizens would help much.
    I think it should be much harder to buy AR-15s. Why an 18 year old could walk in and easily obtain that plus multiple rounds of ammunition is a problem, IMO.

    In almost every mass shooting, there are reports that law enforcement was made aware of a person in distress. Yet, in those cases, there is nothing legally for them to do. You may seem like a wackadoo to me but if you haven't committed a crime -- or, as one of the NRA-killed proposals enumerated, had had a restraining order filed against you -- there is nothing law enforcement can do to take your firearms.

    I'm not in favor of disarming the population, plus, the very idea of it is total fantasy. But I think we need to seriously reconsider access to ammo and in particular firearms that make it easy to waste dozens of people in a matter of seconds, such as the AR-15.

    I'm glad you support expanding background checks. I would hope that if that is done (HINT: It won't be done because half of the Senate will totally stonewall it), it would close the loop that allows private sales and sales at certain gun shows to happen without a background check.

    I agree with hiring security consultants to protect schools, but look at Oklahoma! We don't fund education adequately as it is. Adding entire security protocols seems like a good idea but costs money. If the money is not appropriated this will just be an unfunded mandate, such as the silly window-dressing bill proposed by the legislator in Oklahoma today.

    Making it harder (even almost impossible in some cases) to go out and buy an AR so you can waste a bunch of kids or people in Las Vegas enjoying a country music concert is not an example of "taking guns away from honest citizens." That is how it is reframed and mischaracterized by politicians who are doing the bidding of the gun lobby. Remember, the NRA exists to support gun manufacturers, first and foremost. And, gun manufacturers make a lot of money when people are freaked out and buy lots of guns and ammo. When their members are told firearms are going to be confiscated or outlawed, people run to gun shops and buy more guns and ammo. This has led to a ridiculous and unsustainable number of firearms in our country. It's also led to a precipitous decline in reasonable civic conversations, such as this one, about gun reform. The gun lobby is constantly using fear-based tactics to keep its constituency angry and afraid, which is corrosive to our national politics but keeps people running to buy more firearms.

    It's not like this anywhere else on earth. Other major countries have mental illness, and violent movies, and people who don't go to church, and the Internet, and guess what? They don't have mass school and Wal-Mart and grocery store shootings every other week. We do. Yes, it's cultural, but it's also a result of the ridiculous availability of weapons of mass murder and piles and piles of easily obtainable ammo.

    For someone such as yourself, or someone who is licensed and has to continue to renew their license, such so-called assault rifles could be made available, but there should be a serious background check and follow-up background checks on top of background checks. Further, any weapon like that used in a mass murder through carelessness, such as the one used in Sandy Hook which was not adequately locked up, should make the gun owner culpable in the mass homicide.

    if you have a weapon of mass murder in your home, it should be your responsibility to keep it locked away and secured.

    This is just common sense, and in no way infringes on people's constitutional rights. It shouldn't be easier to buy an AR-15 than a friggin beer. At least in Oklahoma now you can legally buy a joint at 18-- but it still takes longer to get the license for that than it does to buy a ************* AR-15 and go mow down a bunch of elementary kids and their teachers.

  16. #16

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    90% of Americans support background checks. It’s elite Republicans who are funded and lobbied by the NRA that prevent popular laws from passing. These laws could pass tomorrow if even just a couple Republicans cared.

    Unfortunately, there’s a lot of evidence that quantity of guns equals quantity of gun deaths. I’m under no illusion that passing common sense gun control laws will solve the problem. But it could help. And we have to try. No parents should have to go through what happened. And the murderer’s accomplice were Texas Republicans who just recently made it so 18 year old could get a gun without any barriers. You can’t buy a beer or rent a car at 18. It’s all pathetic.

  17. #17

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Thoughts and prayers.

  18. #18

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by dankrutka View Post
    90% of Americans support background checks. It’s elite Republicans who are funded and lobbied by the NRA that prevent popular laws from passing. These laws could pass tomorrow if even just a couple Republicans cared.

    Unfortunately, there’s a lot of evidence that quantity of guns equals quantity of gun deaths. I’m under no illusion that passing common sense gun control laws will solve the problem. But it could help. And we have to try. No parents should have to go through what happened. And the murderer’s accomplice were Texas Republicans who just recently made it so 18 year old could get a gun without any barriers. You can’t buy a beer or rent a car at 18. It’s all pathetic.
    Almost every gun sale in America has background checks. Buying a beer is not a constitutionally protected right.

  19. #19

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by soonerguru View Post
    I think it should be much harder to buy AR-15s. Why an 18 year old could walk in and easily obtain that plus multiple rounds of ammunition is a problem, IMO.

    In almost every mass shooting, there are reports that law enforcement was made aware of a person in distress. Yet, in those cases, there is nothing legally for them to do. You may seem like a wackadoo to me but if you haven't committed a crime -- or, as one of the NRA-killed proposals enumerated, had had a restraining order filed against you -- there is nothing law enforcement can do to take your firearms.

    I'm not in favor of disarming the population, plus, the very idea of it is total fantasy. But I think we need to seriously reconsider access to ammo and in particular firearms that make it easy to waste dozens of people in a matter of seconds, such as the AR-15.

    I'm glad you support expanding background checks. I would hope that if that is done (HINT: It won't be done because half of the Senate will totally stonewall it), it would close the loop that allows private sales and sales at certain gun shows to happen without a background check.

    I agree with hiring security consultants to protect schools, but look at Oklahoma! We don't fund education adequately as it is. Adding entire security protocols seems like a good idea but costs money. If the money is not appropriated this will just be an unfunded mandate, such as the silly window-dressing bill proposed by the legislator in Oklahoma today.

    Making it harder (even almost impossible in some cases) to go out and buy an AR so you can waste a bunch of kids or people in Las Vegas enjoying a country music concert is not an example of "taking guns away from honest citizens." That is how it is reframed and mischaracterized by politicians who are doing the bidding of the gun lobby. Remember, the NRA exists to support gun manufacturers, first and foremost. And, gun manufacturers make a lot of money when people are freaked out and buy lots of guns and ammo. When their members are told firearms are going to be confiscated or outlawed, people run to gun shops and buy more guns and ammo. This has led to a ridiculous and unsustainable number of firearms in our country. It's also led to a precipitous decline in reasonable civic conversations, such as this one, about gun reform. The gun lobby is constantly using fear-based tactics to keep its constituency angry and afraid, which is corrosive to our national politics but keeps people running to buy more firearms.

    It's not like this anywhere else on earth. Other major countries have mental illness, and violent movies, and people who don't go to church, and the Internet, and guess what? They don't have mass school and Wal-Mart and grocery store shootings every other week. We do. Yes, it's cultural, but it's also a result of the ridiculous availability of weapons of mass murder and piles and piles of easily obtainable ammo.

    For someone such as yourself, or someone who is licensed and has to continue to renew their license, such so-called assault rifles could be made available, but there should be a serious background check and follow-up background checks on top of background checks. Further, any weapon like that used in a mass murder through carelessness, such as the one used in Sandy Hook which was not adequately locked up, should make the gun owner culpable in the mass homicide.

    if you have a weapon of mass murder in your home, it should be your responsibility to keep it locked away and secured.

    This is just common sense, and in no way infringes on people's constitutional rights. It shouldn't be easier to buy an AR-15 than a friggin beer. At least in Oklahoma now you can legally buy a joint at 18-- but it still takes longer to get the license for that than it does to buy a ************* AR-15 and go mow down a bunch of elementary kids and their teachers.
    And AR 15 is not a military weapon. And it is not a a very powerful weapon. It is a .223

    Maybe vilifying police and demanding that police not be in schools is a little unhelpful

  20. #20

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by BoulderSooner View Post
    And AR 15 is not a military weapon. And it is not a a very powerful weapon. It is a .223

    Maybe vilifying police and demanding that police not be in schools is a little unhelpful
    Who is doing that? Bizarre cheap shot from you that has nothing to do whatsoever with my post. This is the kind of off-topic comment that you often resort to when controversial subjects are being discussed.

    I don't know what you're trying to suggest here but I don't see anyone here vilifying police. That is a straw man argument that doesn't relate to the discussion up thread.

    Regarding the police, the school in Uvalde had an armed officer on duty, who exchanged gunfire with the assailant. Also, many police arrived quickly but the killer was allowed to continue his assault for up to 90 minutes according to this article.

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...nman-HOUR.html

  21. #21

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by BoulderSooner View Post
    Almost every gun sale in America has background checks. Buying a beer is not a constitutionally protected right.
    Operative word.

  22. #22

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by BoulderSooner View Post
    Almost every gun sale in America has background checks. Buying a beer is not a constitutionally protected right.
    My 16 year old cousin walked into a gun show in Canadian County with cash, walked out with a gun. No questions asked, no ID, nada. I could've done the exact same thing if I wanted to and it's not like this was a decade ago. We are the same age and I am 19 now. You can do the math on that but to correct you, almost every registered gun sale in America has background checks.

  23. Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Hard to understand how we can spend $40B at the drop of a hat on Ukraine miliary aid, but can't do the same thing to harden security at schools--infrastructure changes and an appropriate security guard-to-student ratio for EVERY public school in the nation would be a good start. I just don't get how we can spend for one thing with rapidity, but something like this can't get the same treatment. I feel like hardening school security would have widespread public support and bipartisan political support. That is doing SOMETHING. It is a place to start since gun control legislation can't seem to get traction.

  24. #24

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    If only semantics about AR-15’s not being classified as a military weapon or it using a .223 cartridge eliminates it from being viewed as a “powerful weapon” could have saved those fourth graders at school or those shoppers at the grocery store. Oh well, I guess since it meets the criteria for what is allowed then that relinquishes our responsibility to do anything to attempt to diminish the increasing regularity these events occur.

  25. #25
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    5,225
    Blog Entries
    7

    Default Re: Violence and Mental Health

    Quote Originally Posted by BoulderSooner View Post
    And AR 15 is not a military weapon. And it is not a a very powerful weapon. It is a .223

    Maybe vilifying police and demanding that police not be in schools is a little unhelpful
    Hmm. Then why are both used as the standard rifle and round for the US Military? The M4 is a just a newer derivative of the original 1959 AR-15 and the 5.56×45mm is a nearly identical derivative of the .223 round...

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. Edmond Mental Health
    By blangtang in forum Edmond
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 11-02-2012, 01:25 PM
  2. Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health
    By sabaki in forum Current Events & Open Topic
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 12-13-2006, 07:37 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO