Reid didn't prove his worth until 2006:

From okstate.com:
Football - Roster - Official Website Of Oklahoma State Cowboy And Cowgirl Athletics

Bobby Reid:

PASSING....Att..Cmp..Int..Yds..TD..Lg..Pct
2005..........108..52......4....602....2...49..48. 1
RUSHING....Att..Yds..TD..Lg
2005...........61...139...0....28


Donovan Woods:

PASSING....Att..Cmp..Int..Yds..TD..Lg..Pct
2004..........187....97....5...1628..13..68..51.9
2005...........32.....17....0...163....1...23..53. 1
RUSHING....Att..Yds..TD..Lg
2004..........123..436...10..35
2005...........12...63.....1...18

From ESPN.com:
ESPN - Bobby Reid Stats, News, Photos - Oklahoma State Cowboys - NCAA College Football

Bobby Reid:

PASSING....Att..Cmp..Int..Yds..TD..Lg..Pct
2006..........267.148.....11..2266..24...75..55.4